Possible Planet
by Mark Morton
August 2005

While this release is indispensable to fans of THE DREAM CIRCLE, it should also be on any Roach fan's short list and, in my opinion, is one of the greatest all-modular recordings ever made. As a result any fan of soundscape or electronic music will want this recording. Roach continues to find ways to be creative, but he has outdone himself with the rejuvenating sounds on this masterpiece.

In this age, the concept of "elevator music" has more or less taken over. The distant, soft, unthreatening milieu, so anonymous, has paved the way for computerized "backing tracks" that now dominate the music field. In contrast, music created through improvisation brings with it a definite exploratory feel that, in this new "elevator age" is viewed with suspicion even by those who formerly indulged. I recall a recent interview with a former electronic music improviser who is now enamored of total control, to the effect that previous recordings of his were not worthy of discussion because the sounds were just happened upon and could not be reliably reproduced. The implication was that this was a fault. However, Stravinsky and others have expressed sympathy with the view that the more an artist is willing to work with minimal materials, the more creativity can be profitably generated, in no small part because the element of surprise can become a guide.

Steve Roach's releases generally do not dwell on the equipment used to generate his visionary sounds. "Analog and digital synthesizers and samplers" is usually all the detail you get. But his fantastic new Timeroom release, POSSIBLE PLANET, extensively notes the equipment and, by implication, methods used to create this uniquely expressive tour de force. We are informed that only modular synthesizers were used; specifically no keyboard, MIDI or computer synthesizers.

The use of only modules, which allow the artist to dictate the sonic pathways, can be both daunting and liberating. By avoiding old paradigms of synthesis -- as a piano-type instrument with an extended sonic range -- the artist can begin to create a pure soundstream without being boxed into any traditional linear notions of what to do with the sounds once they are generated. Creation becomes more direct as the musician has to plug and unplug cords and physically twist knobs. A sound, once created, may never be recaptured because there is no way to "store" the exact parameters. This approach brings to mind the statement of jazz musician Eric Dolphy: "When you hear music, after it's over it's gone, in the air. You can never capture it again". Thus, creation has the potential to be more immediate, more in the moment and in the case of POSSIBLE PLANET, more satisfying to create and listen to than music created using other approaches.

"First Murmur" opens the recording and listeners are immediately rewarded as it quickly passes the first sonic stirrings of a primordial bog and transforms itself into a wondeous tapestry of a natural landscape teeming with throbbing life and hinting at potential life. Rich, layered drones predominate and Roach uses modulation and reverb very effectively to transmit the idea that we are listening to something organic, not "music". Crickets, frogs, and atmospheric conditions of a sort abound. One limitation of modular synthesizers, monophony, is transcended with ease through tuning, modulation and multitracking, so that a complex yet relaxed composition is presented.

The pieces flow into one another and before we know it, "Gestation" is underway. Although still within hearing distance of the bog, we are emerging onto a windswept plateau. The drones become more predominant and seem to flow into each other. Stronger winds are heard and the sound painting brings to mind deserted-looking plateaus with activity just below the surface. By this time, the listener is far enough along that he or she should be feeling like they are part of the whole process. Here Roach takes us on his most successful sustained inner organic journey since THE DREAM CIRCLE. The sonic materials remain the same throughout but somehow the presentation varies enough to seem alive, as though the composition was breathing. After about 20 minutes, the winds begin to howl, momentarily peak and then gradually reduce in volume as the piece takes on its own arc, slowly returning to the bog.

The final leg of the journey, "Cell Memory" elevates POSSIBLE PLANET to indispensable status with a historic demonstration of modular virtuosity. Using his long years of programming experience and liberated from the constraints of keyboard interfaces, Roach comibines simple melodic sequences or just triggers short motives to give the impression of a cosmic tilt-a-whirl. The piece is drenched in gorgeous sonics and subtle modulations, with effective use of panning and what sounds like surround sound. Timbral and delay modulations dominate and are marshaled to great effect. Finally the swirling subsides and we are left with the return of the bog sounds and the wind, along with some tasty, guitar-like melodic fragments, with varied attacks and decays to expressive effect.

POSSIBLE PLANET is well-suited to the traditional Timeroom Editions "continuous play" format, and the sonic environments generated have spent many a day morphing in my living spaces. The luxurious analog sounds are best appreciated at a higher volume. While this release is indispensable to fans of THE DREAM CIRCLE, it should also be on any Roach fan's short list and, in my opinion, is one of the greatest all-modular recordings ever made. As a result any fan of soundscape or electronic music will want this recording. Roach continues to find ways to be creative, but he has outdone himself with the rejuvenating sounds on this masterpiece.

Possible Planet

magnify magnify
CD  $15.00 
ON SALE, $10.00 
Box Set out of stock
Possible Planet
Steve Roach
2005 Timeroom Editions 16 (CD)
Reviewed by Peter Grenader, Frank MacEowen, Mark Morton, CD Services (UK), Electroambient Space, e|i magazine, Morpheus Music, Sonic Curiosity, Sonic Immersion

This pivotal new long-form soundworld work pulls back the layers and increases the magnification to reveal a truly organic, analog-based core sound at a level not heard before in Steve's music. The metaphor of emerging lifeforms on a possible planet sets the mood for the three movements presented as a continuous immersive zone. "Wet", "shimmering", "cellular" and "diaphanous" are some words that could describe this living-breathing soundscape.

"While this long from zoneworld was created between December 2004 and May 2005, it developed into a pivotal new release for me. It's also included in The Dreamtime Box because it represents a parallel in some ways to "Looking For Safety" from DREAMTIME RETURN. As an artist if you live long enough to draw a line back in time, the recurring themes can link up to create an interesting graph of stylistic confluence. These two pieces, POSSIBLE PLANET and "Looking For Safety" (recorded in 1986) are at similar points on that graph, with many years in-between them and created in very different circumstances, but still sharing the same air. "During my 'analog rebirth' (see below) this desire started emerging to create a kind of soundscape environment which portrayed an undefined life form as it's just starting to emerge from the primordial soup on some distant planet. The sounds were forming in my imagination and were brought to life as you hear them across three movements. This set the mood for the idea of expressing the emerging, evolving sense of consciousness coming into form."

The Process... "I have always had a visceral connection to the instruments which I choose to channel my energies. Sonically POSSIBLE PLANET is the result of an analog rebirth that started for me last Fall. A series of events created a craving obsession in my imagination and within my ears to hear and create from pure means, not digital to analog converted or virtual analog, frozen waveforms or soft-synths. I wanted to feel the current coming right out of the wall, and shape it from that point forward. POSSIBLE PLANET was created completely on a modular analog system which I assembled over a five-month period. As the sonic life form was evolving, the system that was creating it was evolving as well, in order for the changes to occur. This was also a great metaphor for the themes of the emerging cellular life forms I was dreaming into. "In order to remove the reliable and familiar modes of working, I eliminated a few basics: no MIDI, keyboards of any kind, or computers for composition and editing. It was all about twisting knobs, feeling it in my fingertips and coaxing the current into the desired direction. POSSIBLE PLANET was recorded during three live sessions. Each session would start after several days of creating and learning the nuances of a 'living' patch I had created, from which the soundforms were drawn."
1. First MurmerMP316:01 
2. GestationMP331:26 
3. Cell MemoryMP325:52 

The three movements form a continuous flow. Also available as part of THE DREAMTIME BOX.

Steve Roach News Music Discography Live Press Reviews Store Links Bio Contact